Cas's Peanut Butter and Jelly Recipe and Review

From:
💗Supernatural The Official Cookbook💗

⤷ Bread - two pieces for every sandwich you want to make

⤷ Bacon - (depending on how many sandwiches you want to make) a half package to a full package
⤷ Bananas - We used one banana for two sandwiches (but should have used one and a half in my opinion)
⤷ Smooth Peanut Butter
⤷ Grape Jelly
⤷ Ground Cinnamon
⤷ Butter - about a half of a stick

1. Cook up your bacon to the degree of crispness you like best and set aside
2. Cut your bananas into slices
3. Put a dab of butter into a pan to heat
4. Place your bananas into the pan and sear both sides
5. Sprinkle the ground cinnamon over the bananas to taste then set aside
6. Spread softened butter over one side of every piece of bread your going to use to make the amount of sandwiches you chose
7. For each two slices of bread, put peanut butter on one side and jelly on the other
8. Begin heating up a new pan big enough to fit at least one piece of bread in (if you want to make more than one sandwich at a time, use a bigger pan)
9. Place the jellied piece of bread, butter side down, into a heated pan
10. Add however many bananas you choose on top of the jelly (we used enough to cover the sandwich fully)
11. Add however many pieces of bacon you want on top of the bananas (we used enough to cover the sandwich fully)
12. Place the peanut buttered slice of bread, butter side up, onto the bacon
13. Heat until browned and flip over to brown the other side

Once sufficiently browned, remove the sandwich from the pan and plate up!

Wallah!! You now have Cas's Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich!!

The recipe in the book says it should take 5 minutes of prep time and 10 minutes of cook time.

It took me a little longer then that... more like 10 minutes of prep and 20 minutes of cook time.

• This is a VERY MESSY snack/lunch/meal!!!  Your hands are going to get dirty!! 

• We tried the grape jelly (the flavor noted in the recipe) on one of the sandwiches and a strawberry jelly on the second.  The grape was absolutely delicious! 🍇 The strawberry jelly did not mesh well with the other flavors - I would not recommend it 😷

• I recommend letting any sandwiches you make sit and rest for a good 5 minutes before attempting to eat them.  They are not finger food friendly at first BUT do firm up into a more manageable 'pick up and eat' type sandwich after a few minutes out of the pan.

• These are very filling!!  One sandwich each was enough to tide us over for hours!

• For me, a non-skilled novice cook, searing the bananas was tortuous!  I'm not sure if I had the heat too high or cooked them too long... or maybe I didn't slice them thick enough 🤷 but they turned into mush 😳  Still quite delicious though!

I would absolutely make and eat these again! (but maybe with a couple pairs of gloves handy 😂)

I hope you enjoyed this review!!  If you try it or have already tried it let me know!!!  I would love to hear how it turned out for you!

Interested in this cookbook??  I've conveniently put my affiliate linking for it below ;)
Just remember that by purchasing a product using my affiliate links, there is NO additional cost to you!!  It just provides me with a small kickback to keep the blog running and the giveaways coming!!!

DISCLAIMER:  I was not compensated in any way for this recipe or review.  All cooking utensils and food pictured are my own.  My opinions of the recipe are my own.